Dear webmaster of the Jewish Tribal Review, and Henry Makow, author of "When Victims Rule" What is "Anti-Semitism?" I am sure you know, but take care to share this knowledge with your readers. I encourage you to begin, by finding the integrity to post this email, unedited, on your "Reader's Commentary." It is important, when using your First Amendment Right, that you do not infringe upon it through an ignorance of its limits, and those of your activities. Since your activities involve a national readership, they fall under US law, which they nearly violate. A simple dictionary can explain. 1) Your website fails to provide any definition of "Anti-Semite." By claiming the word is misused censoriously, you use quotes to establish a slippery slope argument which culminates in a vast petitio principi of your postings and writings.

Oh, we do define "anti-Semite." We even examine the many ways Jews define it. We've got over 150 pages on the subject, here, and that's not counting the many other places at this web site where the subject is examined. (Recently, we've posted articles on our home page even entitled "What is an Anti-Semite?")

a- For starters, and we don't need to go beyond this point, here's the dictionary definition of the prefix "anti:" A person who is opposed to something, such as a group, policy, proposal, or practice. Any dictionary will verify.

"Anti-" in the way you're against free speech at this web site?

b- "Semitism." Webster's dictionary provides three main definitions, the second of which contains two words "A Jew." The first and second definitions expand on this.

You know, people like you living their lives through dictionaries really doesn't prove anything. Dictionaries are repositories of information that are changed and censored all the time. Jewish lobbies have succeeded, for instance, in getting the verb "to jew" censored out of some. (We document this at this we site). In other words, dictionaries are the social, political, and ideological products of their editors, who are suseptible to social, political, and ideological pressures upon them.

c- If you wish, key in "Anti-Semitism" on any internet dictionary, or check hardback editions, check Human Rights Organizations and Government Agencies, but the basic meaning of the compound is "Hostility towards Jews" and "Discrimination against Jews"

That is the Jewish-enforced definition. We'd say that "anti-Semitism" is a political tool used by Jews to deflect criticism from them. An "anti-Semite" is today someone who Jews hate. Period.

2) Accordingly, here is what your website amounts to: links to url's of relevance to Jews, pursuing an agenda of establishing a negative picture of this minority.

We post the truth. We post information the public should know about this powerful "minority." What is it that we've posted that you know is not true? You never deny in your email here that anything we state is untrue. You just don't like the fact that such material is placed out in the open.

Your links to the ADL and media articles are framed in a malicious approach to Jewish culture in North America.

You call telling the truth "malicious." What is "malicious" about telling the truth? What is malicious about insisting that Jews take responsibility for their beliefs and actions?

Whether or not you are Jewish, as in the case of Henry Makow, does not alter this fact.

There's "malicious" spin on your citing of this alleged "fact." Two can play at this game, for that is all it is. You fault us for telling truths you don't like publicly known. Nothing more.

3) The fact of your Anti-Semitism is established by the following:

Actually, I hardly care any more if a Jew screams "anti-Semitism" at us. More and more people are getting savvy to its grotesque overuse as a giant scam. The day is coming when calling someone 'anti-Semitic" will be considered a badge of integrity.

a- The articles you hyperlink, are one sided and biased.

We link to mostly Jewish ethnic journals and the mass media. Take up your claims of bias with them. You do your web site with your notion to balance the scales, and we'll do ours. People can look at both of them. Most will reject yours as junk. Propaganda: the same that's been circling the hollow Jewish halo for centuries.

Their content is negative. By singling them out as your sole commentary upon your topic, you are caricaturing Jews and manifesting "hostility."

No. We tell the truth about a very powerful ethnic minority. That's not a crime. That's an expression of democracy -- at least until guys like you take power who demand that the image of Jews be coated in perpetual fluff.

b- Your information is inaccurate.

It is accurate. You don't even cite a single inaccuracy here. Isn't that strange?

When it isn't altogether wrong then its methodology is unsound. Were this not the case, you could have taken your arguments to experts in the field, as any decent university boasts Jewish Studies departments, and synagogues are listed in the Yellow Pages.

Gosh, next time we do a web site, we'll check with you to make sure every post is kosher. Again, the citations at this web site are overwhelmingly from Jewish scholarship, Jewish journals, and the mass media. If you'd rather we cite Ku Klux Klan material to make things easier for you, gosh, you should have let us have known.

Because your material is flawed, this is not an option.

It's right on. It's so right on it has you hopping off your seat with discomfort.

4) Your website, and Makow's book, are not only hostile towards Jews and thus Anti-Semitic, but depredatory to Blacks, Hispanics, and Whites. By implicating minorities (Jews, Blacks, and Hispanics) in the downfall of minorities, you are making a hostile accusation. By depicting Jews as a dominating class, you are depredating everyone's (including white male's) talents and abilities, as well as misrepresenting their status.

Your comments here are completely irrational and make no sense at all. We criticize Jewish power, Jewish ethnocentrism, Jewish history, Jewish hypocrisy, Israel, and so forth. That's it. Your efforts to blend Jewish power and racism into a kind of communal minority victimhood is senseless.

5) You do not free yourself of the responsibility for this hostile portrayal of Jews, by outsourcing to quotes from major dailies. If an academic authority finds 11% of doctors in Weimar Germany being Jewish, you should make the correct conclusion, i.e. that 11% of the people working to better the health and living conditions of post WWI Germany, were Jews.

Horse. People can make whatever conclusion they want. We don't smell altruism. And you are taking this percentage out of the context from which we posted, which evidenced vast Jewish hegemony in Germany's pre-Nazi Weimar Republic.

I.e. Jews, contributed to the human cause, way out of proportion to their absolute numbers. This is positive, and should be lauded, not criticized. In fact, your negative portrayal of Jews, is hostile in the very ingratitude it shows.

What? I should be on my knees to you, kissing the Chosen hand? Sorry. You can spraypaint yourself in gold tinsel, but I'm not interested catching any of your sweat in a cup.

Instead of assailing Jews, consider the tremendous contributions of the Jewish people to humanity!!

Our title page has many categories of the wonderous Jewish contributions to humanity. Apparently you don't like them. Neither do we.

6) The Jewish people have been at the forefront of philanthropy, human rights and welfare, since time immemorial.

Please. Jews are the quintessential chauvnistic, xenophobic, racist tribe.

In ignoring efforts made by a small minority, you are also undermining the price paid for such efforts, the persecution, pogroms, and genocide, meted out by people manipulated by exactly the kind of misrepresentation you construct.

You are a grotesque myth-maker, a Judeo-centric apologist, and you should be ashamed of your dissimulative hucksterism here. Still, I note that you have not refuted a single fact we post at this web site -- and there are many thousands of them. You want the Jewish community to be put on a pedestal to fulfill your hideously self-fawning, ethnocentric illusion. You have nothing else whatsoever to offer.

By rationalizing hostility towards Jews, by initiating it and expanding upon it, you are in fact an Anti-Semite of the worst kind.

If telling the truth offends you, it's a free country and you can call us whatever you like. But you're a moral charleton. And you should be ashamed of yourself.

7) In the USA, any minority is legislated rights. Jews have complied with these rules, to a greater extent than most.

Jews own things "to a greater extent than most." A lot of these "legislated rights" powerful Jewish lobbies were instrumental in forging. In your world view, a "legislated right" might be yours to send me to prison for speaking so freely about Jewish moral failings?

They have not burdened the country's prison system,

Ever hear of Meyer Lansky? Murder Inc.? The Purple Gang? The "Russian" mafia?

and have sacrificed heart and soul to the equal rights of all. Through their effort, they have defended our democracy and our rights. They contribute to our success, wealth, living standards. They serve as teachers of our youth, and paragons of civil conduct.

Again, check out of list of Jewish contributions at our home page.

If there is anyone to whom our gratitude is due for the good and honorable in society, it is to Jews!!!

Plastic bullshit!!!
(Actually, I feel stronger than that about this: !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

You are a classical example of Anti-Semitism,

We have reached the day when telling the truth is grounds for Jewish condemnation. You are a "classical example" of the Jewish Thought Police.

the case of Makow: a failed bar mitzvah.

In your view, because he has some critical ideas about Jews, he's a Jewish "anti-Semite," which is the "self-hating Jew." That's the Jew who breaks rank, tattles on the rest, and falls from tribal grace.

Being a "son of the laws" connotes compassion, honesty, and truth. Hatred, even of oneself, is a violation of the human endeavor.

You "hate" me for telling what you want hidden. That's the beginning and end of it.

Finally, a note to the reader of the Jewish Tribal Review website, and the articles it hyperlinks. If you have a problem with the Jewish people (even if you're Jewish) write down your issues, take them to your local synagogue and ask to speak to someone, who can answer your questions.

Sure. Want to know about Lutherans? Only go to a Lutheran Church. Want to know about Islam? Only go to a mosque. Want to know about communists? Only go to party headquarters. Want to know about Nazis? Only go to Nazi headquarters. Want to know about Jews? Ask you. (You forgot to leave your phone number).

But first, do your own research with a RELIABLE source like the Anti-Defamation League, www.jewishencyclopedia.com, www.hollocaust.com, or just try Judaism, on www.yahoo.com.
Sincerely Ari Perutz

Yay, Anti-Defamation League! The multi-million dollar monolith of objective reporting. Mr. Perutz! We post links to all these kinds of Jewish propaganda organizations at our home page. We're happy if people read their fluff and then compare it to us. That's how people can best understand the enormous scam that's going on. We don't fear a variety of opinions. We know we're right.